Monday, August 25th, 2008

Mini-Review: I-74 Interchange at Ronald Reagan Parkway

ATTENTION: If you want to know if you can use Ronald Reagan Parkway to get to the Indianapolis Airport directly from I-74, the answer is No. The road is not yet completed. You need to take I-465 to I-70 West.

The new I-74 interchange at a newly constructed segment of the Ronald Reagan Parkway in Brownsburg on Indy’s west side recently opened. This will be a major congestion reliever for the main SR 267 interchange, and is a key link in the north-south corridor through eastern Hendricks County. This project was described by some local leaders as Brownsburg’s new front door. The price tag on the project was $18.1 million.

Loyal readers know that I consider the design of transportation facilities to be of paramount importance in the modern age. Not only are these vital functionally, and so have to be rock solid from a design and engineering standpoint, but they also must have a high level of aesthetics and embody the identity and character of the places they pass through. Especially in the Midwest, which lacks stunning mountains or ocean views, the quality of the built environment plays a key role in shaping people’s opinions of a place. They are the new “main streets” of our day, our true public realm and shared space. They send a powerful message about who we are as a people. “For the apparel oft proclaims the man”.

With that in mind, I will tell you that this is a simple diamond interchange with a rather wide spread as is common in more rural interchanges. Both ramp termini are controlled with stop signs. This is probably adequate for now since only a short segment of Ronald Reagan Parkway, about one mile or so from 56th St. to Crawfordsville Rd., was actually built. Signals can easily be added later if warranted.

The road itself features a five lane cross section with shoulders and open ditches. The center lane is basically a TWLTL. There is no raised median. It is constructed of concrete to support the anticipated heavy truck volumes. Here’s a picture.


This cross-section befits a high speed highway and is built to a 55 MPH design standard. This is a quasi-rural design. In fact, replace the concrete center lane with an open grass median and this is basically a standard “expressway” design for INDOT. It is not a road I would describe as a parkway.

Here’s a closer view of the drainage ditches.


Welcome to Brownsburg, indeed.

Interestingly, Hendricks County, Brownsburgh, Avon, and Plainfield spent a great deal of time and money putting together a Ronald Reagan Parkway Master Plan that was supposed to guide the design of the roadway, as well as the land use and development along it. This plan talks a lot about the type of roadway design that was supposed to be envisioned for the corridor (see Section 6). Here’s a quote:

“The Ronald Reagan Corridor Master Plan provides the unique opportunity to establish a design aesthetic and guidelines that will influence both the land use patterns within the corridor and its design aesthetic before it is built. This ability to shape the corridor ‘before it happens’ provides an exciting avenue for establishing a series of goals and having the ability to implement them with less constraints than on an existing roadway enhancement project. The master plan creates opportunities to promote high quality, innovative, and unique design treatments that reinforce the community’s vision for the corridor.” (page 6-2, emphasis added)

I can’t even begin to go into all the detail of what’s in Section 6. It has numerous cross-sections and renderings that show a true parkway, something far closer to Hazeldell Parkway in Carmel than the photo I posted above. But here are a couple of illustrations. First, Figure 6.6, a sample cross-section.

This road clearly beamed in from a different starship than the one I photographed above. Note the curb/gutter section with enclosed drainage. There is no shoulder and no drainage ditches. There is a raised median with extensive landscaping and a highlighted multi-use path on the left side of the roadway. It’s also designed for 45 MPH not 55 MPH operation.

Here’s a rendering of an aerial view of what they anticipated the road looking like. It is Figure 6.8 in the master plan.


What’s the point of a three ring binder sized master plan if you aren’t even going to attempt to follow it? If I lived in Brownsburg, I’d probably think somebody sold me a bill of goods with this master plan.

It would make an interesting case study to see how this project came to deviate so totally from the master plan. All is not lost. Clearly, someone could walk, bike, or jog on the paved shoulder, even if it wouldn’t be too pleasant to have semis zipping past at 55MPH. But it is a protected zone that can be used.

But at the end of the day this roadway is basically yet another mega-highway plopped down in the middle of the suburbs. It displays a lack of conceptual imagination and is designed with the sole apparent goal of functionally moving cars and trucks at high speed, full stop. For an interchange that was supposed to be the new front door to Brownsburg, this is a major opportunity missed.

8 Comments
Topics: Transportation
Cities: Indianapolis

8 Responses to “Mini-Review: I-74 Interchange at Ronald Reagan Parkway”

  1. Kevin says:

    I just finished digitizing the sidewalks in Brownsburg at work. I don’t think I’ve ever seen so many sidewalks that start and stop in the middle of nowhere. That town has got some problems.

  2. thundermutt says:

    The disconnect between transportation builders and transportation planners is staggeringly wide.

    Those “pretty picture plans” like the one you highlighted are often done at a grass-roots level. If they don’t have a powerful advocate (and, to be fair, if they are not practical or realistic) they will never get built.

    Perhaps if state and federal dollars required public input of the “pretty picture plan” type and integrated those sorts of plan-and-design studies into the project plan, the results might be better.

    Indiana turns out some really good planners and designers at Ball State. Too bad INDOT only hires guys from Purdue to design roads.

  3. Gary says:

    I must say the whole west side now has be confused. The agree the I-74 interchange thing is bad. The I-70 into the new airpot seems impossible.

  4. Anonymous says:

    Perhaps Brownsburgh and Avon will build the RR Parkway according to their plans if they ever find the money for it. INDOT built the portion that is so ugly, and they never had a plan for something aesthetically pleasing.

    Finishing the RR Parkway from U.S. 40 to U.S. 136 is one of the most important road projects in the state.

  5. Anonymous says:

    Maybe the rest of the roadway is more parkway, while this is more of an interchange where we might expect to see a Burger King and some warehouses soon? It would fit in with those neighbors.

  6. concernedcitizen says:

    My neighbor just received a letter that the state was taking his house for the RR Parkway. We live in Boone county off of SR 267. How can I get more information on this and whether or not i am next?

  7. Anonymous says:

    Can I use the new Ronald Reagan Parkway to get to the new Indianapolis Airport Terminal? I come in from the west (Crawfordsville)and it would really help.

  8. The Urbanophile says:

    anon 10:58, you can access the airport fairly easily from Ronald Reagan Parkway – however, that road is not yet continuous through the county, so you can’t just exit at I-74 and take it. Until some unknown future date, you’ll need to take I-465

The Urban State of Mind: Meditations on the City is the first Urbanophile e-book, featuring provocative essays on the key issues facing our cities, including innovation, talent attraction and brain drain, global soft power, sustainability, economic development, and localism. Included are 28 carefully curated essays out of nearly 1,200 posts in the first seven years of the Urbanophile, plus 9 original pieces. It's great for anyone who cares about our cities.

About the Urbanophile

about

Aaron M. Renn is an opinion-leading urban analyst, consultant, speaker, and writer on a mission to help America’s cities thrive and find sustainable success in the 21st century.

Full Bio

Contact

Please email before connecting with me on LinkedIn if we don't already know each other.

 

Copyright © 2006-2014 Urbanophile, LLC, All Rights Reserved - Click here for copyright information and disclosures