Search

Tuesday, May 6th, 2014

125 Years of Skyscrapers by Wendell Cox

[ Although his reputation in many urbanist circles is as a defender of sprawl, Wendell Cox happens to be a skyscraper fan. Here's a review he did last year of the history of the world's tallest buildings - Aaron. ]

New_York_World_Building_New_York_City.jpg
The New York World Building (1890-1955).

Skyscrapers have always intrigued me. Perhaps it began with selling almanacs to subscribers on my Oregon Journal paper route in Corvallis. I have continued to purchase almanacs each year and until recently, the first thing I would do is look in the index for "Buildings, tall” in the old Pulitzer The World Almanac, the best source until the Internet.

My 1940 edition is the first in which “Buildings, tall” appears. The world of skyscrapers has changed radically through the years. This article provides a historical perspective on the world’s tallest buildings, using information from almanacs and the Internet (See Table Below). Extensive hyperlinking is also used, principally to articles on particular buildings.

The Rise of Commercial and Residential Buildings

Throughout most of history, the tallest habitable buildings have been religious edifices, or mausoleums, such as the great pyramids of Egypt. But in the middle to late 19th century, taller commercial and residential buildings were erected in the United States. For four years, from 1890 to 1894, the New York World Building, itself was the tallest in the world, at 309 feet (95 meters) and 20 floors. But it was not until the turn of the 20th century that a commercial or residential building exceeded the tallest religious building, Ulm Cathedral in Germany. This was Philadelphia’s City Hall. In its wisdom, however, Philadelphia outlawed any building higher than William Penn’s head at the top of City Hall. It was not until the late 1980s that a taller building appeared in Philadelphia (One Liberty Place).

Tallest Buildings in 1940

Despite Chicago’s claim as birthplace of the skyscraper, by 1940, nine of the 10 tallest buildings in the world were in New York. Manhattan was so dominant that the World Almanac listed the city at the top of the list, out of alphabetical order. The five tallest buildings, the Empire State Building, the Chrysler Building, 60 Wall Tower (now 70 Pine), 40 Wall Tower (now the Trump Building) and the RCA Building (now the GE Building) all opened in the 1930s and represent Art Deco at its zenith. The sixth tallest, the Woolworth Building, had been the world’s tallest from 1913 to 1930 and is neo-Gothic.

Cleveland’s Terminal Tower was 7th tallest, and the tallest building in the world outside New York. Cleveland’s Union Terminal was in the building and served the legendary New York Central Railroad’spremier New York to Chicago 20th Century Limited.

Tallest Buildings in 1962

Things changed little by 1962. The five Art Deco skyscrapers that where the tallest in 1940 remained so in 1962. There were two newcomers to the top 10 list, both modernist monoliths, the Chase Manhattan Bank Building in lower Manhattan and the Pan Am Building (later the Met-Life Building). The Pan Am Building is despised by many New Yorkers as Parisians despise the Tour Montparnasse. This led to banning similar behemoths in the ville de Paris (most of the skyscrapers in the Paris urban area are in La Defense, a nearby suburban “edge city”). But all of the 10 tallest buildings in the world were in the United States.

Tallest Buildings in 1981

Just two decades later, New York’s dominance eroded. By now, The World Almanac listed New York in alphabetical order, between New Orleans and Oakland. For the first time since before 1908 when the Singer Building opened, New York was not the home of the world’s tallest building. That title had gone to Chicago’s, Sears Tower (later Willis Tower), which opened in 1974. Chicago gained even more respect with two other buildings appearing in the top 10, the Standard Oil Building (now Aon Center) and the John Hancock Center, which was the tallest mixed use (residential and commercial) building in the world. The twin towers of the former New York World Trade Center were tied for second tallest in the world.

For the first time, a non-American skyscraper was in the top 10. Toronto’s First Canadian Place was the eighth tallest in the world. Only three of the former five New York Art Deco buildings remained in the top 10, with 40 Wall Tower and the RCA Building no longer on the list.

Tallest Building in 2000

By 2000, Kuala Lumpur, which is not among the largest cities in the world, emerged with both of the tallest buildings, in the Petronas Towers. The Petronas Towers ended America’s long history of having the tallest building. These distinctive postmodern towers were just two of six Asian entries in the top 10, including another postmodern structure, the Jin Mao Tower in Shanghai’s Pudong, which is probably the world’s largest edge city.

I recall my surprise at exiting the Guangzhou East Railway station in 1999 to see the CITIC Tower, the 7th tallest building in the world. There could have been no better indication of that nation’s modernization. The Pearl River Delta had two other of the tallest buildings, one in Shenzhen (Shun Hing Square), the special economic zone that became the economic model for the rest of China, and the second in Hong Kong (Central Plaza).

Tallest Building in 2013

By 2013, the world of skyscrapers had nearly completely overturned. Dubai, with a population little more than Minneapolis-St. Paul, is now home to the world’s tallest building, the Burj Khalifa. The Burj Khalifa is not just another building. Never in history has a new tallest building exceeded the height of the previous tallest building by so much. Even the long dominant Empire State Building had exceeded the Chrysler building by only 200 feet (64 meters). The Burj Khalifa was nearly 1050 feet higher (320 meters) than the then tallest building, Taipei 101, and reaches to more than 1/2 mile (0.8 kilometers) into the sky. The world’s second tallest building (the Mecca Royal Hotel Clock Tower) is also on the Arabian Peninsula.

The Shanghai World Financial Center is now the fourth tallest in the world, and when it opened had the highest habitable floor and the highest observation deck in the world. Its unusual design has earned it the nickname "bottle opener" among residents (Photo 1). Hong Kong has a new entry in the list, the International Commerce Center, across the harbor in Kowloon. Nanjing’s Greenland Financial Complex (Photo 2) ranks 8th, and Shenzhen’s Kinkey 100 ranks 10th.


Photo 1: Jin Mao Tower (left) and Shanghai World Financial Center (right), Shanghai. Construction began later on the recently topped out Shanghai Tower to the right of the Shanghai World Financial Center.


Photo 2: Greenland Financial Center, Nanjing

Nine of the 10 tallest buildings in the world are now in Asia. The last American entry is the Sears Tower (Willis Tower), in Chicago, which ranks 9th. Skyscraperpage.com maintains a graphic of the world’s tallest buildings (Note 1).

Under Construction

A number of super-tall buildings (Note 2) will soon open. Earlier this month, the Shanghai Tower was “topped out.” This structure is across the street from the Jin Mao Tower and the Shanghai World Financial Center, forming by far the greatest concentration of super-tall skyscrapers in the world (Photo 1). The Ping An Finance Center in Shenzhen and the Wuhan Greenland Center in Wuhan are also under construction, and will rank, at least temporarily, second and third tallest in the world when completed. The Goldin Finance Building in Tianjin and the Lotte World Tower in Seoul will be somewhat shorter. One World Trade Center in New York will be completed before most of these, which will allow it brief entry into the top ten.

Another entry, Sky City in Changsha (Hunan) could be on the list, slightly taller than the Burj Khalifa. This building is to be constructed in 210 days, following site preparation and work began last month. It was, however, halted by municipal officials and there are conflicting reports as to the building’s status.

Skyscraperpage.com also maintains a graphic of the world’s tallest under-construction buildings.

Tallest Buildings in 2020?

None of the tallest buildings in the world are predicted to be in the United States by 2020, according to a graphic of current plans posted on the Council on Tall Buildings and Urban Habitat website. The Burj Khalifa is expected to be replaced as tallest by another Arabian Peninsula entry, the Kingdom Tower in Jeddah, which will be 0.6 miles high (3.3 kilometers). The torch has been passed to Asia.

WORLD’S TALLEST COMPLETED BUILDINGS: 1940-2013
1940 Building City Feet Meters Stories
1 Empire State New York 1,250 381 102
2 Chrysler New York 1,046 319 77
3 60 Wall Tower (70 Pine Street) New York 950 290 66
4 40 Wall Tower (Trump) New York 927 283 90
5 RCA New York 850 259 70
6 Woolworth New York 792 241 60
7 Terminal Tower Cleveland 708 216 52
8 Metropolitan Life New York 700 213 50
9 500 5th Avenue New York 697 212 60
10 20 Exchange Place New York 685 209 54
1962 Building City Feet Meters Stories
1 Empire State New York 1,250 381 102
2 Chrysler New York 1,046 319 77
3 60 Wall Tower (70 Pine Street) New York 950 290 66
4 40 Wall Tower (Trump) New York 927 283 71
5 RCA New York 850 259 70
6 Pan Am (Met-Life) New York 830 253 59
7 Chase Manhattan New York 813 248 60
8 Woolworth New York 792 241 60
9 20 Exchange Place New York 741 226 57
10 Terminal Tower Cleveland 708 216 52
1981 Building City Feet Meters Stories
1 Sears Tower (Willis Tower) Chicago 1,454 443 110
2 World Trade Center-North Tower New York 1,350 411 110
2 World Trade Center-South Tower New York 1,350 411 110
4 Empire State New York 1,250 381 102
5 Standard Oil (Amoco) Chicago 1,136 346 80
6 John Hancock Center Chicago 1,127 344 100
7 Chrysler New York 1,046 319 77
8 Texas Commerce Tower Houston 1,002 305 75
9 First Canadian Place Toronto 952 290 72
10 60 Wall Tower (70 Pine Street) New York 950 290 66
2000 Building City Feet Meters Stories
1 Petronas Tower 1 Kuala Lumpur 1,483 452 88
1 Petronas Tower 2 Kuala Lumpur 1,483 452 88
3 Sears Tower (Willis Tower) Chicago 1,454 443 110
4 Jin Mao Tower Shanghai 1,381 421 88
5 World Trade Center-North Tower New York 1,350 411 110
5 World Trade Center-South Tower New York 1,350 411 110
7 Citic Plaza Guangzhou 1,283 391 80
8 Shun Hing Center Shenzhen 1,260 384 69
9 Empire State New York 1,250 381 102
10 Central Plaza Hong Kong 1,227 374 78
2013 Building City Feet Meters Stories
1 Burj Khalifa Dubai 2,717 828 163
1 Mecca Royal Hotel Clock Tower Mecca 1,971 601 120
3 Taipei Taipei 101 1,670 508 101
4 Shanghai World Financial Center Shanghai 1,614 592 101
5 International Commerce Center Hong Kong 1,588 484 118
6 Petronas Tower 1 Kuala Lumpur 1,483 452 88
6 Petronas Tower 2 Kuala Lumpur 1,483 452 88
8 Greenland Financial Complex Nanjing 1,476 450 89
9 Sears Tower (Willis Tower) Chicago 1,454 443 110
10 Kinkey 100 Shenzhen 1,450 442 100
  Outside United States
  United States, Outside New York
  New York

 

Wendell Cox is a Visiting Professor, Conservatoire National des Arts et Metiers, Paris and the author of “War on the Dream: How Anti-Sprawl Policy Threatens the Quality of Life.”

———————

Note 1: There are a number of sources for information on tall buildings, such as the Council on Tall Buildings and Urban Habitat, Skyscraperpage.com, Emporis.comand Wikipedia.com. Of course, my favorite will always be The World Almanac, even if the Internet provides faster access. Wikipedia also has fascinating articles on individual buildings (Wikipedia’sutility is limited to recreational research for identifying original sources, and should never be used in serious research, or God forbid, used in a footnote).

Note 2: The Council on Tall Buildings and Urban Habitats defines a super-tall building as being over 980 feet (300 meters) high.

This post originally appeared in New Geography on August 24, 2013.

2 Comments
Topics: Architecture and Design, Urban Culture
Cities: New York

2 Responses to “125 Years of Skyscrapers by Wendell Cox”

  1. Lou says:

    Its too bad Wendell Cox doesn’t understand history. Philadelphia never had a ban on buildings taller than city hall instead it was a gentleman’s agreement. The city had a lousy economy after WWII with a stagnant office district like many downtowns before the 1980’s office boom. One Liberty place that broke the agreement was built in 1985, mid eighties. It was quickly followed by half a dozen other skyscrapers that are very elegant from afar but not great at street level with barren plaza and very little retail.

    Also characterizing La Defence as a “suburban edge city” is just plain wrong. Its not suburban or edge. Its Paris’s second downtown connected to the region by subway, bus, light rail, and regional rail. Its also borders the city proper (1860 limits) and if in american would be considered a extremely dense urban area.

  2. Alon Levy says:

    La Defense is something that doesn’t really exist in the US (but exists in Canada): a CBD that is an edge city in scale and age but as tall, dense, and transit-oriented as a traditional CBD. La Defense has some dreary plazas, as do the newer parts of Lower Manhattan, but the correct comparison is to Manhattan and not to Tysons Corner.

The Urban State of Mind: Meditations on the City is the first Urbanophile e-book, featuring provocative essays on the key issues facing our cities, including innovation, talent attraction and brain drain, global soft power, sustainability, economic development, and localism. Included are 28 carefully curated essays out of nearly 1,200 posts in the first seven years of the Urbanophile, plus 9 original pieces. It's great for anyone who cares about our cities.

Telestrian Data Terminal

about

A production of the Urbanophile, Telestrian is the fastest, easiest, and best way to access public data about cities and regions, with totally unique features like the ability to create thematic maps with no technical knowledge and easy to use place to place migration data. It's a great way to support the Urbanophile, but more importantly it can save you tons of time and deliver huge value and capabilities to you and your organization.

Try It For 30 Days Free!

About the Urbanophile

about

Aaron M. Renn is an opinion-leading urban analyst, consultant, speaker, and writer on a mission to help America’s cities thrive and find sustainable success in the 21st century.

Full Bio

Contact

Please email before connecting with me on LinkedIn if we don't already know each other.

 

Copyright © 2006-2014 Urbanophile, LLC, All Rights Reserved - Copyright Information