Aaron M. Renn

All Things Aaron

  • Home
  • Bio
  • Press
  • Archives
    • By Date
    • By City
    • Podcasts
    • Reviews
    • Articles in Governing Magazine
    • Articles in the Guardian
    • Articles in City Journal
    • Articles in New Geography
  • Get Posts by RSS
  • Podcast

St. Louis Blues

June 24, 2019 By Aaron M. Renn

My latest article is online in City Journal and is a look at the most recent failed attempt to merge St. Louis city and St. Louis county governments in light of the backdrop of civic challenges there. Here’s an excerpt:

Better Together, a drive to consolidate the governments of St. Louis County and its towns with the city of St. Louis, was over almost before it started. Following political blowback and the indictment of the St. Louis County executive who would have run the merged government, backers withdrew the proposal. But the problems that prompted it—regional demographic and economic malaise, fiscal distress, and segregation—aren’t going away. Attempts to shake up the region’s governance are likely to continue.

St. Louis is a rare “independent city”—not located within a county, that is, but existing as its own separate entity. Baltimore and some cities in Virginia are also organized this way, but few others. St. Louis was once part of St. Louis County. In 1876, however, city officials, unhappy with the county government, managed to push through a secession in which a newly enlarged city was carved away from the county. Practically speaking, the independent city of St. Louis was equivalent to a combined city-county government. In 1950, its peak population year, St. Louis was the eighth-largest city in the United States, with a population of 856,796, which even today would make it our 18th-largest municipality—bigger than Seattle, Denver, or Boston. Its land area of 62 square miles exceeds those of San Francisco and the District of Columbia. For a long time, independent St. Louis thrived, and separation from the county looked like a smart move.

Click through to read the whole thing.

Share This Post:

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Print

Related

Filed Under: Aaron M. Renn

Comments

  1. Rod Stevens says

    June 24, 2019 at 1:19 pm

    There are a couple of reasons public service doesn’t matter. First, the people with influence over public policy live elsewhere, in gated communities where they send their kids to private schools, or the enclave equivalent to them.

    Second, governments don’t want accountability. There are no few direct metrics for how well they perform. If there were, people would be fired.

    Third, we have low expectations of government. Those expectations are so low that it is easy to meet them.

    • basenjibrian says

      June 24, 2019 at 6:46 pm

      These are VERY broad generalizations, Rod. And certainly not the case in many cities and towns.

      I wonder what “accountability” was imposed on the financial Masters of the Universe who invented the “financial engineering products” that have helped decimate the American economy? (read the fun little tale in the recent NYTimes about Remington) How many executives responsible for the recent debacle at Boeing have lost their jobs?

    • P Burgos says

      June 27, 2019 at 11:39 pm

      Reading the comments on City-Journal yields what you would expect; lots of defenses of segregation. I am of the opinion that the US’ unique urban planning and governing challenges mostly are the result, either directly or indirectly, of segregation (or the desire for segregation). Guns, and the reasonable fear that armed criminals generate, probably also play a large role as well.

      • basenjibrian says

        July 1, 2019 at 8:53 pm

        America’s foundational crime. Some argue (unconvincingly but interestingly) that the Revolution was all about preserving the Peculiar Institution and its wealth-generating economy in the face of changing opinions in Metropolitan Britain.

        Read a fascinating story about how Saint George of Mount Vernon was so…aggrieved…by a slave who ran away. (A young woman…I wonder if he was a jilted lover?) that he directed the Attorney General of the United States to undertake a search for his lost “property”. Almost Trumpian in its pettiness.

Get my eBook The Urban State of Mind for your Kindle from Amazon.

About Aaron M. Renn


 
Aaron M. Renn is an opinion-leading urban analyst, consultant, speaker, and writer on a mission to help America’s cities and people thrive and find real success in the 21st century. (Photo Credit: Daniel Axler)
 
Email: aaron@aaronrenn.com
Full Bio

Trending Posts

  • Nine Reasons Why Detroit Failed
  • New England vs. Midwest Culture
  • Heartland Intelligence
  • Suburban Blight in Kansas City
  • Coronavirus and the Future of Remote Work

Disclosures

Links on this site may contain embedded “affiliate codes.” Purchases made through these links may result in a payment to me.
 
Header design by Carl Wohlt.
Header images via Shutterstock.

Copyright © 2006-2020 Urbanophile, LLC, All Rights Reserved - Click here for copyright information and disclosures